Electronic Magazine of Multicultural Education

FALL 2002     http://www.eastern.edu/publications/emme    Vol. 4, No. 2

Theme: Gender Identity and Politics

| This Issue | Articles | Instructional Ideas | Open Forum | Reviews | Authors |
| Dentith | Lee | Morgan | Ross |

[ Art Reviews | Book Reviews | Multimedia Reviews ]

 

BOOK REVIEWS


Literature for Young Readers

Cole, Babette. (1997). Prince Cinders. New York: Putnam Publishing Group. 32 pp., ISBN: 0-69811-554-6 (pbk), $6.99 (ages 4-8).

This new twist on the original Cinderella story will delight boys and girls of all ages. Cinders, the runt of the family, is relegated to cleaning up beer cans and macho magazines after his three big masculine older brothers who spend their time at the Palace Disco with their princess girlfriends.  Finally, one night as Cinders is doing a load of his brothers' dirty socks, a fairy drops down the chimney and tries to help improve the plight of poor Cinders.  Unfortunately, most of the spells go wildly amok as the fairy gives Cinders a swim suit in her attempts to create a fashionable suit and she accidentally turns him into an ape when trying to give him a more "buff" masculine look.  Nonetheless, Cinders looks in the mirror and thinks he looks dashing; he jumps in a little red sports car (the one item the fairy got right) and heads off to the Palace Disco.  The remaining events of the night result in Cinders meeting Princess Lovelypenny on the public transit system and the loss of his pants (not glass slippers) as the princess tries to find out his name.  Ending in the happy union of Cinders with Princess Lovelypenny, this book will help children realize that love goes beyond being skin deep and gives an alternate view of  princes and princesses.

Cole, Babette. (1997). Princess Smartypants. New York: Putnam Publishing Group. 32 pp., ISBN: 0-69811-555-4 (pbk), $5.99 (ages 4-8).

Dealing with the theme of marriage, this book follows the free-spirited, beautiful, and wealthy princess as she is forced to take on suitors.  Through a clever plan Princess Smartypants requires all her suitors to pass unconquerable tasks before she will consider their affections.  Finally, Princess Smartypants meets her match in Prince Swashbuckle, who easily overcomes all her challenges.  To the readers surprise, as the Princess rewards this cocky and overconfident Prince with a kiss, Prince Swashbuckle is turned into a toad.  This is enough to keep all other suitors from bothering Princess Smartypants and she gets to live happily ever after as a single with all her favorite pets and her liberating motorcycle.  While still putting a female in the role of a beautiful princess who must get married (the theme of many "traditional" princess stories), this book does send the message that it is acceptable to remain unmarried and that marriage may not be a preferable option for some young ladies.  This excellent book will challenge some traditional female stereotypes.    

Erdrich, Lise & Fifield, Lisa (illustrator). (2002). Bears Make Rock Soup and Other Stories. San Francisco, CA: Children's Book Press. 32 pp., ISBN: 0-89239-172-3 (hc), $16.95 (ages 4-8).

Focusing on the roles of Native American women, this collection of stories presents a new perspective on Native American folklore.  While the author's main goal of this book is to present the stories of how humans are connected with nature, she tells it through a mainly feminine perspective.  Most of the stories in this book focus on women, their children, and/or grandmothers: how they help animals, the earth, and all things in nature to grow, learn, heal and find peace.  The story, "The Bears that Couldn't Hibernate," highlight women who gently persuade the hungry bears to listen to a bedtime story that eventually puts them to sleep.  In "Forest of the Deer Spirits." women also "sang and made healing smoke" to help the deer spirits return to the spirit world.  Several other stories tell about the sacred dance that Native American women perform to honor the animals of the earth.  This book, through both exquisite words and pictures, shows how Native American women play an integral part in the maintenance of the human-nature connection.     

Heron, Ann. (Ed.). (1994). Two Teenagers in Twenty: Writings by Gay and Lesbian Youth. Los Angeles, CA: Alyson Books. 182 pp., ISBN: 1-55583-282-2 (pbk.), $12.95 (ages 12-adult)

This collection of essays contains 43 writings by gay and lesbian youth, ranged from 12 to 24 years old.  As a sequel to One Teenager in Ten, published by the same publishing company 10 years prior to this publication, the book follows the same format of presenting the voices of youth as voluntarily submitted. Various topics are covered with regard to their personal experiences with homosexuality or bisexuality.  The common themes throughout the writings are clear in that homosexual inclination is not a personal choice; many teenagers discovered their sexual orientation early in their lives without having a name for it; "coming out of the closet" is a highly risky decision, which had caused many teenagers friendships and family supports; those who were accepted by families, friends, and other significant adults fared better in their development after coming out; and gay and lesbian teenagers have the same intellectual and emotional needs to be met as straight teenagers. This book must be read by youth and adults working with adolescents regardless of their preconceptions of homosexuality if they honestly desire to be better informed of adolescent affairs and to serve this population more effectively.

Keens-Douglas, Richard & Lafrance, Marie (illustrator). (1998). The Miss Meow Pageant. New York: Annick Press. 24 pp., ISBN: 1-55037-536-9 (pbk), $6.95 (ages 4-8).

This story of a gender-confused cat will delight readers of all ages.  Poor Sparrow is so ugly.  Or is she so beautiful...or is she a he?  These questions and more are both asked and answered as readers glide through this brightly illustrated tale of Sparrow and the Miss Meow Pageant.  Sparrow's owner, Henrietta, and her friend Len decide that even though Sparrow is a male cat (so they think) Sparrow should be allowed to participate in the exclusively female feline beauty contest.  As we watch Len and Henrietta train Sparrow for the pageant, readers begin to recognize that beauty is not only a feminine trait.  But to everyone's surprise, Sparrow undeniably declares her gender as she gives birth to the most beautiful kitten in the world while on-stage at the pageant.  This wonderful story will act as a springboard into discussions regarding gender stereotypes for young readers.

Jennings, Kevin (Ed.). (1994). Becoming Visible. Los Angeles, CA: Alyson publications, Inc. 296 pp., ISBN: 1-55583-254-7 (pbk), $13.95 (ages 14 & up).

"So, why teach gay history?", exclaims the editor of this book in the introduction.  Jennings argues that we must teach the gay history to our high school and college students because it will help create a more tolerant society and "it is intellectually dishonest not to do so."  Drawing from his own experiences as a gay high school student, Jennings recognizes that teaching the gay history will help all students increase awareness and give gay students a sense of roots, heritage, and pride.  This edited book draws upon both primary and secondary sources as it traces the presence of homosexuality throughout the last 2,000 years of world history.  The first of three parts of this book provide readers with definitions of heterosexism, homophobia, and homosexuality as well as a historical overview.  The following parts focus on the "emergence of the modern gay movement" during the period between the late 1800s and the 1960s and "the ongoing struggle" from 1968 to the present.  After each very readable chapter, questions and suggested classroom activities are presented to assist with lesson planning.  This is a valuable resource to any history educator wishing to incorporate gay history into the high school or university curriculum.

Munsch, Robert & Martchenko, Michael (illustrator). (1980). The Paper Bag Princess. New York: Annick Press. 25 pp., ISBN: 0-920236-16-2 (pbk), $6.95 (ages 4-8).

Princess Elizabeth, faced with the destruction of her castle and the kidnapping of her soon-to-be-husband prince Ronald, decides to find the horrible dragon and rescue her betrothed Prince Ronald.  Since her old clothes were burnt by the dragon, Princess Elizabeth dons a paper bag and begins her quest.  After outwitting the horrible dragon and setting her Prince free, Princess Elizabeth is met with hard criticisms from Prince Ronald about her un-princesslike appearance.  Princess Elizabeth walks off into the sunset without her ungrateful, chauvinistic Prince Ronald and lives happily ever after.  This humorous story sends an assuring message to readers about women's (and girls) potential to break through sex-role stereotyping.  This book, a pioneer of a slowly growing genre of non-traditional prince and princess stories, introduces a positive image of an empowered woman for children and adults alike.

Perez, Amada Irma & Gonzalez, Maya Christina (illustrator). (2002). My Diary from Here to There. San Francisco: Children's Book Press. 31 pp., ISBN: 0-89239-175-8 (hc), $16.95 (ages 4-8).

This autobiographical tale depicts the journey of a young girl who moved  with her family from Mexico to the United States. Throughout the book readers will be able to see into the mind of young Amada.  Her fear of leaving behind her best friend and annoyance with her brother's playfulness and apparent disregard to the weightiness of their move are expressed with a uniquely feminine perspective on immigration.  With a focus on issues of a more feminine and interpersonal nature, readers will learn about strained family relations between mothers, grandmothers and sisters as Amada and her family live with various relatives while waiting for their father to send for them to come to the United States.  This well-written and vividly illustrated bi-lingual (Spanish/English) book will provide readers of all ages a more feminine view on the immigration process.  

 


Professional Literature

Gallas, Karen. (1998). "Sometimes I Can Be Anything": Power, Gender, and Identity in a Primary Classroom. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University. 153 pp., ISBN: 0-8077-3695-3 (pbk.), $18.95.

A practicing teacher-researcher offers keen observation and insightful interpretation of gender dynamics in first and second grade classrooms in this readable book.  As exemplified by excellent works published in the Practitioner Inquiry Series, of which this book is part, this practitioner research artfully interweaves stories of real children with rich qualitative data on gender-based interactions.  The reader is invited to peek into daily interactions between boys and girls and to discover with a surprise the delicate power play and dominance practiced by some boys and "survival strategies," such as silence and all-around friendliness, employed by some girls.  In the course of two years of working with the same children in "looped" first/second grade classrooms, the author was able to trace the progress of gender identity formation during the early years of schooling.  Despite the teachers' conscientious efforts to practice gender equity in instructional settings, the reality of forces relegating girls to the more passive, silent, and secondary position can be readily witnessed.  Although this work was an emotionally difficult piece to write according to the author, such a painfully candid piece reminds educators that much work is needed to raise gender-equity consciousness in teachers as well as in children, as young as first and second graders.  

Grobman, Laurie. (2001). Teaching at the Crossroads: Cultures and Critical Perspectives in Literature by Women of Color. San Francisco, CA: Aunt Lute Books.  206 pp., ISBN: 1-879960-63-X (pbk.), $21.95.

This book presents a perfect marriage between theory and practice as well as between multicultural education and multiethnic women's literature.  Attempting to interconnect the "separate strands of critical and pedagogical perspectives vis-à-vis texts by women of color" (p. 5), the author proposes the "teaching at the crossroads" paradigm that integrates Western-based, ethnic-specific, mainstream feminist, and ethnic-specific feminist approaches.  Using Sandra Cisneros' The House in Mango Street and Leslie Silko's Storyteller, the author demonstrates how to teach at the crossroads of genre.  Toni Morrison's Beloved and Maxine Hong Kingston's China Men are utilized in the author's pedagogical discussion of identity. An extensive list of classroom exercises as well as a bibliography of literary criticism categorized by ethnic groups are appended to enhance the critical understanding of these literary works written by a Chicana, a Native American, an African-American, and an Asian writer.

Haag, Pamela. (1999). Voices of a Generation: Teenage Girls on Sex, School, and Self. Washington: American Association of University Women Educational Foundation.  95 pp., ISBN: 1-879922-21-5 (pbk.), $14.95.

This research report grew out of 150 Sister-to-Sister summits sponsored by the American Association of University Women in 38 states between November 1997 and July 1999, in which girls of 11 to 17 years of age listened to presentations and participated in small group discussions.  The author collected data from approximately 2,000 girls who responded to six open-ended questions given at registration. Girls candidly and perceptively voiced their opinions of the unrealistic societal expectations of girlhood communicated in the mass media; their perspectives on sex, teen pregnancy, sexual harassment, inter-sex respect, sexual violence, and sexual identity; their struggles with peer pressure, self-esteem, and friendship; and their attitudes about academic achievement.  The voices of girls allow the reader to peek into their sophisticated world of internal conflicts intertwined with self-assurance and self-pride.  This is an invaluable source for teachers and parents of teenage girls.

Koch, Janice, Sanders, Jo & Urso, Josephine.  (1997). Gender Equity Right From the Start: Instructional Activities for Teacher Educators in Mathematics, Science, and Technology. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.  135 pp., ISBN: 0-8058-2337-9 (pbk), $24.00.

This comprehensive collection of activities is designed to provide teacher educators with instructional ideas and activities that can challenge their students' thinking of gender equity especially with regard to mathematics, science, and technology education.  The book covers six equity issues: (1) math, science, and technology as male domains; (2) peers', teachers', parents', and society's cultural expectations; (3) biased and inappropriate curriculum materials; (4) classroom interaction and atmosphere; (5) anti-intellectualism and attributional style; and (6) testing and assessment.  For each area, numerous easy-to-use and useful activity ideas are provided with labels indicating appropriate situations of use (e.g., "in class," "out of class," and "field") and appropriate levels and subject areas (e.g., "elementary science," "science," "mathematics," and "technology").  This book is to be used with the resource book that is reviewed in the following entry.  The last part of the book also contains a list of actual action research projects implemented in various universities in the United States.  

Koch, Janice, Sanders, Jo & Urso, Josephine.  (1997). Gender Equity Sources and Resources for Educational Students. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.  120 pp., ISBN: 0-8058-2887-7 (pbk), $16.00.

This outstanding resource book for education students is a companion copy of the instructional activities book for teacher educators previously reviewed in this Book Review section. The goal of the project that yielded this excellent result is to help pre-service teachers become aware of socio-cultural impediments that keep girls from pursuing careers in math, science, and technology and implement gender-equity curriculum when they become professional practitioners.  The resources represent the depth and richness of existing research of gender issues in education, including articles, primary documents, statistics, vignettes, fact sheets, activity ideas, professional guidelines, reading list, electronic resource list, and organization list.  

Westfried, Alex H. (2002). Reinventing the Culture of Womanhood in America and Brazil, an Anthropological Perspective . New York: University Press of America.  118 pp., ISBN: 0-7618-2276-3 (pbk), $29.00.

book cover image The author summarizes the book as "a story of Brazilian women's journey to independence, against overwhelming obstacles, in a country where the myth of masculinity was well established" (p. vii).  Following a brief historical overview of the feminist movement in Brazil since the 1964 transition from a military regime to democracy, stories of ten "innovative," emancipated women are interwoven with anthropological interpretations of gender roles, religion, family structure, and economic needs of this country.  Despite the lingering expectation of traditional gender roles, these accomplished middle-class women pursued careers in traditionally male-dominant professions such as those of an attorney, politician, scholar, university president, and corporate executive.  Brazilian women, including these feminist leaders, have contributed to bringing about advancement to women's education and employment conditions.  Free federal university education, substantial maternity leave, affordable day care services, and extended family structure have assisted Brazilian women to seek employment outside home while parenting.  By juxtaposing cultural resources and impediments of these two countries the author outlines what the United States could learn from the Brazilian feminist movement in terms of working women's conditions.  While his argument is in essence compelling, the comparison between the Brazilian and US conditions, relegated to the last two short chapters of the book, is simplistic and anecdotal.  Careful proofreading could have enhanced the joy of reading this informative text of the Brazilian women's movement.


[TOP] [HOME] [ABOUT EMME] [CURRENT ISSUE] [PREVIOUS ISSUES] [SUBMISSION INFORMATION] [ACKNOWLEDGMENTS] [WRITE TO THE EDITOR]

Editor-in-Chief: Heewon Chang, Ph. D.
Copy Editor: Christopher Bittenbender, Ph. D.
Art Review Editors: Hwa Young Caruso, M. F. A. & John Caruso, Jr., Ph. D.
Assistant Editor: Julie Shaw

E-Mail: emme@eastern.edu

Eastern University
Education Department

1300 Eagle Rd.
St. Davids, PA, 19087-3696

Copyright © 2002 by EMME & Authors
All hyperlinks to other sites are provided for user convenience only;
EMME does not endorse  the linked sites and is not responsible for the content of these sites.