|
THIS
ISSUE
REVIEWS:
+++
Heewon Chang, Ph. D.
Eastern
University
|
Darren E. Lund
We often hear the saying that “youth are the
leaders of tomorrow” but I would like to echo the words of Roger
Clark, the former Secretary-General to Amnesty International
Canada, who disagrees with this statement. “Youth are
not the leaders of tomorrow.” He insists, “They are the
leaders of today!” For over 16 years I have had the
privilege of working with hundreds of young people who eagerly
take on voluntary leadership roles in school-based coalitions
dedicated to promoting the values of multiculturalism through
local and global activism. [paragraph 1]
Many educators are choosing to engage
students in addressing diversity through antiracist and
multicultural education. Broadly framed, multicultural education
in Canada has been informed to some degree by federal policies
on cultural pluralism; Canada remains the only nation with
multiculturalism formally entrenched in its constitution. Those
educators with an eye to more critical considerations of
systemic racism and the variety of students’ complex identities
will find a wealth of multicultural research and academic
writing to support their planning. For example, Banks (2002)
offers a multidimensional view of multicultural education that
encompasses teachers’ efforts in prejudice reduction, designing
equity pedagogy, and fostering an empowering school culture and
social structure (pp. 13-20). He argues for conceptualizing the
school as a “unit of change” and for “restructuring the culture
and organization of the school so that students from diverse
racial, ethnic, and social-class groups will experience
educational equality and empowerment” (p. 17). In this light,
teachers and students working together toward equality can be
viewed as important change agents, both locally and beyond
school walls. [paragraph 2] For students or educators wishing to mobilize a coalition to address equity concerns, there are a number of accounts in the educational literature of activists who have had success with promoting social responsibility in US schools (Nieto, 1999; Sleeter, 1996). Nieto writes about creating multicultural learning communities using recent research and teachers’ narratives, while Sleeter emphasizes social activism as a means of addressing diversity issues in schools. In addition, Canadian school activists and scholars offer similar success stories of teachers and students promoting multiculturalism and pluralism (e.g., Berlin & Alladin, 1996; Corson, 2000; Dei & Calliste, 2000; Smith & Young, 1996). [paragraph 3]
Each of these writers addresses
cultural pluralism within the broader context of a growing
recognition of the need to understand and respect diversity
while acknowledging a broader, global picture. Global education
is arguably a separate field from multicultural education, but
there are many ways in which the two overlap in schools. Banks
(2002) argues that educators must “help our students attain the
knowledge and skills they need to function in a culturally
diverse future society and world” (p. 23). By gaining
understandings of the interconnectedness of all peoples living
on the earth, students are likely to gain empathy for the lives
of others. [paragraph 4]
Learning how to begin to take
multicultural action in a particular school or community can
seem a daunting task. Below I offer a brief overview of the
formation and activities of one particular student action
project and offer some suggestions from my experiences and
research for forming and sustaining such coalitions to address
diversity issues on local and global levels. [paragraph 5]
Students Taking Action on Multicultural Issues The STOP (Students and Teachers Opposing Prejudice) group formed spontaneously in an unlikely nonacademic literature class during my rookie year of teaching high school English at Lindsay Thurber Comprehensive High School that is located in Red Deer, a small city (population about 70,000 people) in the province of Alberta in western Canada. It remains a popular extracurricular school program and has been widely recognized for leadership in innovative approaches to challenging racism and other forms of discrimination (i.e., Alberta Human Rights and Citizenship Commission, 2000; Canadian Race Relations Foundation, 2001). In addition, STOP was honored with a 2001 Award of Distinction from the Canadian Race Relations Foundation, and was named “Freedom Fighter of the Month” for March 2000 by the rock band, Rage Against the Machine (see <www.ratm.com>). [paragraph 6]
In what could be considered a volatile social
climate, the STOP program actively engages students, teachers,
parents, administration, other school staff, government, media,
and community agencies in a collective effort to promote
fairness through socially responsible action. More detailed
information about the STOP group’s efforts appears in other
sources (e.g., Lund, 1998; 2000). The intense initial national
media interest in the group was most likely due to central
Alberta’s unfortunate national reputation for extremist hate
group activity (Kinsella, 2001). The STOP actions began at the
local level and expanded to encompass global issues.
[paragraph 7]
Students who formed STOP realized
that they could take proactive steps toward educating others on
the dangers of discrimination and the value of diversity, rather
than confronting right-wing extremists. When the Central Alberta
town of Provost endured a publicized cross-burning at a hate
rally, STOP members volunteered a weekend to work with students
there. STOP members became aware that in the early 1980s, two
homes in Red Deer had been targets of cross-burnings, later
reported in Baergen (2000) and Kinsella (2001). Together the
students shared ideas and resources in a collective effort to
counter hatred. When a Sikh man was denied entry into Red Deer’s
Royal Canadian Legion meeting room because he was wearing
unauthorized “headgear” (his turban), STOP members wrote
compelling letters to the parties involved and to the media.
STOP also invited the victim to address a group of about 300
high school students and shine light on Sikh faith.
[paragraph 8]
STOP laminated a set of Holocaust
posters given to the group by the Simon Wiesenthal Centre in
Toronto and donated them to the school district for educational
use by teachers and community agencies. The group also purchased
additional archival material on the Holocaust from the U.S.
National Archives and often shares these resources with the
local museum. Student interest led STOP to organize an annual
Holocaust Awareness Symposium in conjunction with the Calgary
Jewish Centre. Since 1994, several actual survivors of Nazi
concentration camps have spoken to thousands of high school
students. [paragraph 9]
Many activists show openness to
taking on global projects that may not seem on the surface to be
multicultural issues, but have a fairness component at their
core. One example from STOP’s experience is its protesting of
Shell Oil’s ongoing mistreatment of the Ogoni people and their
land in Nigeria. On the surface it appears to be a situation
better addressed by an environmental issues club but, upon
closer examination, is really about what Dr. Owens Wiwa--brother
of slain writer-activist Ken Saro Wiwa--calls “environmental
racism.” Inviting both Dr. Wiwa and a high-ranking Shell Oil
official to the school to speak to hundreds of students, and
organizing a well-publicized legal protest of a local Shell gas
station, helped expose students and others in the community to
the brutal oppression of a community of people by a
multinational corporation that apparently values its own profits
over the health and well-being of those people (Lozeron, 1999).
In a community where the predominant livelihood is based on the
oil business, this was risky school activism, but the students
insisted on analyzing the situation in a country halfway around
the globe to reveal the social justice concerns at its core.
More importantly, they decided to take positive action toward
social change. [paragraph 10]
Other international awareness
campaigns for the STOP group have included fundraising for
overseas earthquake relief, supporting community development in
Honduras by sponsoring a child through Foster Parents Plan,
raising local concern for sexual victimization among street
children around the world, and helping to promote the message of
Canadian child rights activist, Craig Kielburger (Kielburger &
Major, 1998). STOP has also supported our school’s international
and immigrant students, helping organize intercultural events
and awareness programs. In addition, student members also
volunteer their time to local refugee committees and immigrant
serving agencies. [paragraph 11]
In 1999, two STOP student leaders
initiated and organized an ambitious project on human rights
issues in Tibet. Their efforts involved participation by local
and national politicians, organizing and sending petitions,
showing videos, booking guest speakers, mounting local protest
events, holding a symbolic flag-raising ceremony, and inviting
other students to get educated and involved (Srubowich, 1999).
The students’ efforts caught the attention of local and national
media, and the students saw their concerns raised formally in
the Canadian Parliament. They also received an official response
from our country’s Minister of Foreign Affairs. [paragraph
12]
Additional STOP activities have
included awareness campaigns on violence against women,
including annual “white ribbon” campaigns and a gender-inclusive
“Take Back the Night” event that features films, speakers, a
march to City Hall, and a candlelight vigil for all victims of
violence. In 2000, STOP formed Alberta’s first-ever Gay/Straight
Alliance program to raise awareness and prevent discrimination
against gays and lesbians in the school and community (Kennedy,
2000). Specific student and teacher activism has included the
interrogation of school policies and curriculum materials,
presentations to government officials, drama presentations to
children, organizing local protests, international human rights
advocacy, and public debates with political leaders.
[paragraph 13]
In each of these activities,
students and teachers have found a way to work together to
address needs in their school, community, and around the globe
in a manner that models the cooperation and respect the STOP
group seeks to promote. So many students have a strong sense of
social justice and the energy and idealism to seek to make
progressive changes in our society, and all they need is a
vehicle to channel their ideas and energy. [paragraph 14]
Suggestions for Forming a Multicultural Action
Group
The following suggestions are
intended to offer other educators, students and community
activists some helpful encouragement to initiate or extend their
own activism. Social justice coalitions could be based in a
school, across several schools, in a non-governmental agency in
the community, under the umbrella of an existing organization,
or as part of a college or other institution. These suggestions
are derived from my own experiences informed by insights from
other educators I interviewed for an AERA award-winning research
study (Lund, 2001). My own experience has been in a large public
high school in a small western Canadian city, but these starting
points may have relevance across a variety of other settings.
[paragraph 15] 1. Establish a guiding principle for the project
Like many of the participants I
interviewed for my doctoral research, the STOP group formulated
a vision for its activism at the outset that would let all
interested staff and students know what it was about. As an
example, a guiding principle could be to promote the belief that
people should be judged based on their own merits, rather than
on characteristics like age, gender, religion, “race,” ethnic
background, physical appearance, sexual orientation, or other
factors unrelated to the quality of their character.
[paragraph 16]
In the case of STOP, its brochure and
other literature stresses education over confrontation, but
members are not afraid of challenging racism, sexism,
homophobia, and other various forms of narrow-mindedness and
discrimination that exist. Addressing systemic inequities and
other hidden barriers can also be stated explicitly in a
statement of principles or goals. A solid basis for any group
concerned with social justice in the world can be found in the
first article of the United Nations’ Universal Declaration of
Human Rights: “All human beings are born free and equal in
dignity and rights.” 2. Organize and promote an initial meeting
The lessons from the most successful
and longest standing social justice groups--along with those
whose efforts did not materialize into a lasting program--point
to the importance of early efforts to mobilize like-minded
friends and peers to help organize the group. Activists are
advised to set a meeting time and place and spread the word any
way possible. It is important to establish a meeting spot that
is easy to find and accessible to the widest variety of people
possible. I recommend using word-of-mouth, flyers, e-mail, web
sites, school bulletins, posters, signs, or whatever other ways
that might be effective to inform and mobilize interested
people. [paragraph 18]
STOP usually announces in the
school’s printed school bulletin in September. Even if only a
few people show up, the publicity may have already signaled a
new focus on diversity in the school, and it only takes a few
committed people to start to make a difference. The group can
use its early meetings to brainstorm on new ways to recruit
other members, including creating eye-catching posters, using
the school’s audiovisual equipment to produce promotional ads,
creating a permanent school display, or even handing out flyers.
Maintaining a regular meeting time and date helps establish
stability in the program through a consistent routine for its
members. [paragraph 19] 3. Become—or find—an enabling adult facilitator
If you are a teacher or
administrator who wishes to start an activist coalition with
students in the school, you may wish to offer to serve as the
group’s advisor. Achieving a balance of having meaningful input
into the group’s direction and sitting back to allow young
people to take ownership of the group is a difficult task. Other
teacher activists with whom I have spoken talk of mediating this
constant tension. Student activists seem especially aware of the
potential value to a group of a respectful adult who can perform
the role as liaison with the school’s administration, while
allowing enough room for autonomy and the students’ agency in
the organization. [paragraph 20] 4. Find relevant issues on which to focus
With a guiding principle in mind,
activist groups need to sharpen their focus. Finding specific
issues to tackle may require some flexibility and negotiation,
but this step will provide a useful starting point for possible
activities of a fledgling group. Members of activist groups such
as STOP and the others whom I interviewed all admit sometimes to
wanting to do too much, to spread themselves a bit thin, but
there are endless justice issues across the planet that need
addressing. The prevailing attitude seems to be, “If we don’t
address this issue, who will?” A good starting point would be to
brainstorm a list of “hot issues” surrounding diversity and the
acceptance of differences and try to set priorities for each
action based on that particular community’s greatest needs,
considered in light of the group’s resources and members’
individual interests. [paragraph 21]
These are just a few of the possible
areas of interest for activist groups just starting out: (a)
countering organized hate group activity in the school or
community; (b) addressing human rights issues on a national or
international level (capital punishment, government torture,
political prisoners, rights of children, child labor, oppression
of women, and the like); (c) dealing with racist or sexist humor
in the school; (d) confronting and understanding injustices
faced by Aboriginal peoples at home and in other countries; (e)
addressing the discriminatory treatment of young people by the
media or local businesses; (f) exposing and eliminating
discrimination based on sexual orientation; (g) critiquing
hiring policies of local school districts, city staff, and
corporations; (h) examining gaps in human rights legislation and
enforcement; (i) uncovering historical examples of racism from
the local community and nation; (j) exploring cultural or ethnic
diversity in the community and nation and making links to the
countries of origin of its citizens; (k) examining the divisions
between cliques or peer groups in a school; (l) monitoring
local, national, and international news coverage of diversity,
immigration, human rights, discrimination; and (m) eradicating
sexual harassment, gender inequities, and gender discrimination.
[paragraph 22] 5. Find reliable sources and do the necessary homework
Student and teacher activists alike
remind us of the importance of researching one’s topics well.
Since each activist group will likely be consulted as a source
of reliable information on social justice issues, it seems
reasonable to wish to consult as many resources as possible.
There is a wealth of relevant information on a wide variety of
topics, available through reputable web sites, local experts,
government and non-government diversity-serving agencies, local
and national news media sources, the public library, magazines,
newspapers, and professional videos on the topics. [paragraph
23]
In addition, some activists
regularly consult scholarly sources in planning and situating
their own work. Local colleges and universities have an
abundance of resources, both academic and professional, for
educators and students to utilize. As shown in the example of
the STOP group above, school activists can choose to take action
on any number of issues in their local community, region,
province, country, or on a global scale. A warning from some
students with whom I have spoken advises seeking a balance in
sources of information consulted. They also recommend developing
and using critical skills to recognize the biases in all
reporting and specific techniques used in propaganda as well as
to see what the core issues are in apparently complex
situations. [paragraph 24] 6. Become organized
Volunteer activist programs seem to
work best when specific roles and responsibilities are
designated. Even those groups whose members are reluctant to set
up a hierarchical structure with official titles have found it
useful to have a lead person or team on a specific event. In
this way, one person becomes identified as a source for
coordinating tasks and timelines so that plans get made and
activities organized. Groups that attempt to involve as many of
the members as possible in each event or undertaking tend to
encourage a higher level of commitment and ownership in the
group. It seems apparent that maintaining an egalitarian and
consensus seeking framework within such groups helps to model
the cooperation and harmony that it seeks to inculcate in the
broader society. [paragraph 25] 7. Seek administrative approval and support It seems a prudent idea to inform the central office staff and principal’s secretary once an activist group has been organized in a school. School diversity activists may be amazed at the volume of materials received annually by each school around social justice, diversity, and cultural issues, so many of which typically may get filed or discarded. Founding a program that addresses these issues also means that there is now a central clearinghouse for all social justice materials. [paragraph 26]
With the administration’s support,
many of the excellent resources that become available to a
school-based group can be purchased by the school itself, the
students’ council, the parent or school council, or the school
district, as well as through the group’s own fund-raising.
Winning over a reluctant administration through strategic
framing of initiatives—using terminology such as promoting
fairness, building harmony, reducing violence, maintaining safe
and caring schools, or celebrating diversity—can invigorate the
membership and relevance of a coalition that can then continue
its work toward challenging racism and other systemic forms of
oppression within a supportive environment. [paragraph 27] 8. Strengthen existing social justice networks
The overwhelming consensus from
research participants and my own years of activism is that the
work seems more rewarding when other agencies and groups are
involved. Many activists speak of an additional layer of
coordination required when an outside group joins in the
planning or implementing of a specific undertaking, but they
recognize the many benefits of organizing joint projects with
groups with similar goals. One benefit is that each group gains
new perspectives on the issues being addressed, as its members
learn to work across differences in approach and priorities.
Often other people have done similar work or addressed related
concerns, saving the other partner valuable time and energy.
When organizing work on international issues, this partnership
building with reputable groups is especially beneficial.
[paragraph 28]
Some possible community contacts
include offices of international aid and human rights agencies,
local immigrant/refugee serving agencies, women’s shelters and
crisis centers, service clubs, youth associations, police race
relations and community relations committees, antiracist and
multicultural community and school committees, gay and lesbian
support groups, and teacher association committees on diversity,
human rights, and social justice. [paragraph 29] 9. Get attention and raise awareness in a variety of ways
Members of groups that reported the
highest rate of success—in attracting new members and
maintaining continuity from year to year—recommended that new
groups try to create a positive stir in the community. Members
of activist programs can use all kinds of ways to share their
message and attract attention to these social justice issues.
Suggestions for creative ways to garner this awareness raising
include drama presentations, interactive theatre, street
protests, awareness events in relevant and legal public places,
musical concerts, comedy, posters, puppets, face-painting and
costumes, petitions, public debates, charity fund-raisers, and
participation in community forums. [paragraph 30]
Many activist group members will
issue press releases and regularly write letters to the editor
and even guest editorial opinion columns on issues of relevance.
Even after an awareness event has taken place, groups may
consider sending a few good photos with a detailed commentary to
a local newspaper outlet; they often appreciate the information
and may decide to provide coverage even as a light feature,
another small step in helping to share key messages.
[paragraph 31] 10. Have fun
A final note must include recognizing
the sense of optimism that seemed to pervade each of the
thriving groups with whose members I spoke. Even though this
work takes its members into the ugly and often discouraging
underbelly of human cruelty, hatred, and apathy, it also offers
great promise for a better future. There is also the potential
for some serious community and political backlash to organized
diversity work, no matter how careful the activities have been
planned (Lund, in press). Some activists see this as a good sign
that their efforts are making a positive difference, but the
resistance or hostility can be demoralizing nevertheless. Those
activists who seem to enjoy the greatest rewards from this
struggle somehow manage to strike a balance—between facing the
unpleasant realities of racism and other oppression and
sustaining the shining hope of achieving a more equitable and
fair world as an end goal. [paragraph 32]
The ten points above are not intended
to be an exhaustive or prescriptive list of foolproof ways to
foster multicultural activism, but rather, are suggestions that
have emerged from the lived experiences of veteran and rookie
activists alike. As in my experiences with the STOP program,
each can be adapted as it suits a particular school or community
setting. I hope these suggestions offer a starting-off point for
those who seek to initiate projects in their community or abroad
or simply provide a boost for more experienced activists already
working in coalitions. We can all be encouraged by the words
presumed to be said by Margaret Mead: “Never doubt that a small,
group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world.
Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” I would strongly
recommend to young people with an interest in social justice to
begin immediately to take individual and collaborative action in
their schools and communities. As today’s leaders, they can
teach us adult activists a great deal about commitment,
enthusiasm, and relevance in our collective efforts to make the
world a better place. [paragraph 33]
Alberta Human Rights and Citizenship
Commission. (2000, May). Tools for
transformation: Human
rights
education and
diversity
initiatives in Alberta.
Edmonton, AB: Government of Alberta.
Baergen, W. P. (2000). The Ku Klux Klan in
central Alberta. Red Deer, AB: Central Alberta Historical
Society.
Banks, J. A. (2002). An introduction to
multicultural education (3rd ed.). Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
Berlin, M. L., & Alladin, M. I. (1996). The
Kipling Collegiate Institute story: Towards positive race
relations in the school. In M. I. Alladin (Ed.), Racism in
Canadian schools (pp. 131-146). Toronto, ON: Harcourt Brace.
Canadian Race Relations Foundation. (2001). CRRF 2001 Best practices reader. Toronto, ON: Author.
Corson, D. (2000). A pan-Canadian research
program for more inclusive schools in Canada: The diversity and
equity research background. In Y. Lenoir, W. Hunter, D.
Hodgkinson, P. de Broucker, & A. Dolbec (Eds.), A
Pan-Canadian education
research
agenda (pp. 167-191). Ottawa,
ON: Canadian Society for Studies in Education.
Dei, G. J. S., & Calliste, A. (2000). Mapping
the terrain: Power, knowledge and anti-racism education. In G.
J. S. Dei & A. Calliste (Eds.), Power, knowledge and
anti-racism education: A critical reader (pp. 11-22).
Halifax, NS: Fernwood.
Kennedy, C. (2000, November 20). New student
group fights anti-gay bias at local high school. Red Deer
Advocate, p. A1.
Kielburger, C., & Major, K. (1998). Free
the children. Toronto, ON: McClelland & Stewart. Kinsella, W.
(2001). Web of hate: Inside Canada’s far right network
(2nd. ed.). Toronto, ON: Harper Collins.
Lozeron, J. (1999, May 1). Activist
leads protest against Shell activity. Red Deer Advocate,
p. A2.
Lund, D. E. (1998). Social justice activism
in a conservative climate: Students and teachers challenging
discrimination in Alberta. Our Schools/Our Selves, 9(4),
24-38.
Lund, D. E. (2000). Young people mobilizing
on human rights issues. In G. S. Bhatia, J. S. O’Neill, G. L.
Gall, & P. D. Bendin (Eds.), Peace, justice, and freedom:
Human rights challenges for the new millennium (pp.
199-206). Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta.
Lund, D. E. (2001). Social justice
pedagogy and teacher-student activism: A collaborative study of
school-based projects. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, B.C.
Lund, D. E. (in press). Rising to the
challenge: Student antiracist activists counter backlash and
stereotyping. Teaching Education Journal.
Nieto, S. (1999). The light in their eyes:
Creating multicultural learning communities. New York, NY:
Teachers College Press.
Smith, J., & Young, J. (1996). Building an
antiracist school: The story of Victor Magel School. In K. A.
McLeod (Ed.), Multicultural education:
The state of the
art national
study, Report #4 (pp.
57-66). Winnipeg, MB: Canadian Association of Second Language
Teachers.
Sleeter, C. E. (1996). Multicultural
education as social activism. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Srubowich, S. (1999, October 27).
STOP stands up for Tibet. Red Deer Express, p. 3. Darren Lund, Ph. D., is past President of the Alberta Association for Multicultural Education. He has received several honors for his work, including the first Alberta Human Rights Award (1987) and 1996 Reader’s Digest National Leader in Education. (Contact the author at dlund@ucalgary.ca; contact the editors of EMME at emme@eastern.edu.) Recommended Citation in the APA Style:
Lund, D.
(2003). Building global awareness: |