|
Open-access
E-journal for
International Scholars, Practitioners, and Students of Multicultural
Education
ISSN:
1559-5005
Copyright © 1999-2006 by
Electronic Magazine of Multicultural Education
THIS
ISSUE
(SPRING 2003: vol. 5, no. 1)
Theme:
Urban
Education and Reform
ARTICLES:
Hurley •
Fallahi •
Blanc et al. •
Bauer et al.
REVIEWS:
Art
•
Books
•
Multimedia
CONTRIBUTORS
+++
Call for Papers
Call for Reviewers
Issue Themes
Acknowledgments
About EMME
About the Editors
Heewon Chang, Ph. D.
Editor-in-Chief
?
Copy Editor
Hwa Young
Caruso, Ed. D. & John Caruso, Jr. , Ph. D.
Art Review Editors
?
Assistant Editor
Eastern
University
Education
Department
1300 Eagle Road
St. Davids, PA,
19087-3696
|
MULTIMEDIA REVIEWS
(provided
by the editorial staff of EMME unless indicated otherwise)
Films
and Videos
Children in America's
Schools with Bill Moyers: They're a bunch of flowers growing in
a garbage can. (1996). 120 minutes,
color. Produced by Jeffery Hayden & Kelley Cauthen. Distributed
by
SCETV.
 |
Based on Jonathan Kozol's
Savage Inequalities: Children in America's Schools,
the video contains two parts: the first part documents
educational inequalities existing in Ohio public schools
and the latter part presents a discussion of ten
panelists and questions from teachers, students, and
parents featured in the documentary. Disparities in
school facilities and resources between poor and
affluent communities are visually striking in the video
as in Kozol's book. While some schools have to educate
children in dilapidated facilities, without bathrooms or
lunch services and with coal heating, leaky ceilings,
cracked walls, limited instructional and physical
spaces, and outdated and deficient instructional
materials, other schools boast modern buildings equipped
with Olympic-size pools, state-of-the-art science and
computer labs, well-stocked libraries, several indoor
and outdoor exercise facilities, and ample instructional
materials. It is not surprising that students from the
latter schools express enthusiasm for learning and
optimism for their futures whereas despair and
frustration could be easily detected in the voices of
students from the former. The panel discussion,
facilitated by Bill Moyers, focuses on what to do about
these inequalities. While some continue to support
local funding for education and personal choices through
vouchers, Kozol and others are highly critical of the
current educational funding structure that relies on
local resources. The plea for taking a national
responsibility for providing adequate education to all
children of the nation needs to be heard and thoroughly
examined if the nation cares about its children, they
argue. The documentary is worth watching. Although the
panel discussion does not lead the viewers to an easy
conclusion, it is thought-provoking and may begin a
dialogue at the school and community level. |
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Listening to America with
Bill Moyers: Unequal Education.
(1992). 60 minutes, color. Produced by Howard Weinberg.
Distributed by
PBS Video.
 |
Though the campaign debates
between George Bush, Sr. and Bill Clinton have all but
gone the way of the dinosaur, the politics of education
are still going strong in our current administration.
While the first
fifteen minutes of this film documents the heated
political climate of the late 1980's and early 1990's,
Moyers spends a considerable amount of time focusing on
a project completed by four recent New York City High
School graduates. This project details the striking and
shocking differences between two New York City junior
high schools. One school (Riverdale Junior High School)
located in an economically privileged section of the
Bronx, hires fully certified teachers, provides students
with a myriad of after-school activities, and is well
equipped with books and resources. The other school (I.
S. 137), located in the economically disadvantaged area
of the Bronx, South Fordham, struggles with finding
certified teachers to hire, spends a large amount of
time and resources on safety issues, and tries to get by
without adequate materials and resources for teachers.
This documentary follows one student from each of these
schools over a six-month period and portrays trials and
successes of each student as they go through the school
year. Moyers then bounces from this film into an
expanded discussion of how to "fix" the plight of
unequal school funding, he does this by moderating a
debate between Jonathan Kozol, a proponent of switching
school funding sources from local communities to the
federal government and John Chubb, a strong proponent of
school choice and vouchers. Moyers in his usual style
pulls together a thought- provoking program that will
make any viewer think hard about America's educational
system and the equity of that system. The video is a
decade old; yet the excerpt portraying educational
inequality in urban settings still speaks to the present
time. It is a must-see for educational policy makers as
well as the general public. |
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
School The
Story of American Public Education: The Bottom Line in
Education: 1980 to the Present. (2001). 55 minutes, color.
Produced by Sarah Mondale & Sarah B. Patton. Distributed by
Films for the Humanities and Sciences.
 |
Part of a four-video series
documenting and commenting on the history of public
schools in the United States, this video tells the story
of K-12 education in American schools from the 1980s to
the present. Narrated by Meryl Streep, the video opens
with a sunny picture of schools in America where over
85% of all high school graduates went to college in the
1980s and then enters the era of Ronald Regan and his
policy to break up the "public school monopoly" and to
increase competition in the education sector with
parental choice. When the economic times changed,
politicians began to blame schools for the fiscal
downturns and the focus of schools went from one of
equity to one of excellence, as evidenced by the
landmark publication of "A Nation At Risk." The "A
Nation At Risk" report led to demands for measurable
results from the education sector through high-stakes
testing. In some schools, principally those in urban
America, the video reports that much help was, and still
is, needed to raise the academic bar. Drawing upon the
expert opinions of scholars in education, both successes
and failures of school choices and vouchers are
examined. This video will be a great asset to any
pre-service or in-service teacher who wishes to learn
about the history of education in America and the role
of business politics in this endeavor. The foundation
that this film will provide to educators will help make
meaning out of current educational trends and
philosophies in this new era including the No Child Left
Behind legislation. |
Websites
ERIC Clearing House on Urban
Education
http://eric-web.tc.columbia.edu
This specialized clearinghouse in the ERIC system,
funded by the Office of Educational Research and Improvement of
the U.S. Department of Education, is a national information
service and database focusing on urban education, urban reform,
and research. The site is easy to navigate and provides a wealth
of information on the following topics: education of African
Americans, Latinos, Asian Americans, Pacific Islanders, other
ethnic and racial groups, and newly arrived immigrants. There
are two easy ways to browse the site: one is through the Major
Subject Areas Link that will allow users to select from a menu
of the following broad subjects: Student Learning and
Development, Schools and Schooling, Urban/Minority Families and
Communities, Social/Economic Factors, and Equity & Diversity.
Clicking on any one of these links will take the user to a menu
of links on more specific topics pertaining to each broad
subject area. The second way to browse the contents of this site
is to click on the pathways link. This link will connect users
with a pathway page that contains links to other internet sites
related to the pathway topic chosen. Pathway topics include:
Alternatives to Expulsion, Asian/Pacific American Studies,
Bilingual Reading Instruction, Closing the Achievement Gap,
Family Literacy, A Guide to Welfare Reform, Immigrant Education
Issues and more. In addition to access to thousands of articles,
books and research on urban education, the site also provides
opportunities to publish research in the area of urban
education. This site is a must for any teachers, administrators,
teacher educators and researchers interested in Urban
Education.
Hope for Urban Education: A
Study of Nine High-Performing, High-Poverty Urban Elementary
Schools.
http://www.ed.gov/pubs/urbanhope/
This report tells the story of nine urban elementary
schools that served minority children in poor communities and
also achieved impressive academic results, in some cases results
beyond those of some suburban schools. The authors also attempt
to explain how these schools came to these high results and the
changes they had implemented. Though all nine schools used
federal Title I money to create Title I programs within their
schools, the funding only supported the change efforts and thus
Title I was not the catalyst of the change. All nine schools met
certain criteria regarding income, location, admission policy,
and student achievement, but all schools were also different in
many areas. The schools varied in enrollment, grade-level
configurations, cultural demographics, and school reform models.
The stories of these nine schools will be of interest to
administrators of academically struggling schools, teacher
educators and researchers focusing on school reform.
Metro Center for Urban
Education
http://www.nyu.edu/education/metrocenter/
While the homepage may be misleading, after users delve
a bit deeper there are many useful resources on this site
regarding urban education. This site, created and maintained by
New York University, provides information and services to
schools and school districts that serve diverse learners,
include high poverty areas, have multiple barriers to providing
high-quality education, struggle with safety and drug-related
issues, and/or require equity assistance. Some of the programs
that are supported through the Metro Center include: The Equity
Assistance Center (EAC) which assists states and school
districts in areas of desegregation, achievement gap, and issues
related to race, gender and national origin; The Upward Bound
program; Teacher Opportunity Corps; Tutoring Programs; and
Liberty Partnerships program. In addition to supporting these
various programs, the Metro Center also provides links to
publications, teacher resources, student links, and breaking
news on equity issues in education. Access to three
urban-focused newsletters are also available through the Metro
Center Web site, including the Equity Bits and Bytes newsletter,
the LEAD (Language Equity Access and Diversity newsletter), and
the SDFS (Safe and Drug Free Schools) newsletter.
Mural Arts Program
http://www.muralarts.org/
This public art program, located in Philadelphia,
partners with community residents, non-profit and grassroots
organizations, government agencies, educational institutions,
corporations and others to create murals of "enduring value
while actively engaging youth in the process." This web site not
only chronicles their monumental efforts through an online
gallery (incomplete), but also provides users access to many
other valuable resources. Students, parents, and teachers have
access to valuable Arts Education Programs including a year-long
"Big Picture," whose curriculum not only exposes students to the
"history and process of mural painting" but also involves
students in designing and completing a small mural. Other
programs include a job shadowing program and youth art show.
While this might be of the value to those living in the
Philadelphia region, this site can be of use to those in other
urban areas, providing a template for creating an urban mural
arts education program for youth living in and around major
cities.
National Urban Alliance
http://www.nuatc.org/index.html
The National Urban Alliance, founded in 1989, sponsors
this web site that assists in fulfilling its mission to "promote
effective, accelerated student learning, as demonstrated on
standardized, alternative measures of assessment...." This site
educates users about the NUA approach to urban educational
reform and gives researchers, administrators, and teachers the
resources to begin school reform programs of their own. Users
are provided access to the numerous NUA projects and specific
details regarding goals, objectives, components, access to
guidelines, and more on each NUA project. Access to articles
published by and of interest to the NUA is also available to
users, topics ranging from literacy to achievement gap. Users
are also provided with many other useful resources, such as
links to handouts from previous presentations and conferences,
web links to hundreds of additional sites that focus on urban
education and reform, and access to purchase publications used
and created by the NUA. This site should be a part of any urban
educator's list of internet favorites.
No Child Left Behind
http://www.nclb.gov/
The No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) of 2003 will
invariably be of paramount importance to all schools, but for
urban schools this new legislation creates an accelerated need
for reform in an effort to reach government mandated adequate
yearly academic progress levels. This site, though geared
towards parents and other lay persons, will provide educators
and administrators the government perspective on the NCLB
legislation. Links to frequently asked questions, fact sheets,
and statistics help to untangle this complicated education
reform initiative. Users are encouraged to register for The
Achiever newsletter that chronicles the current administration's
activities regarding education and reform, provides access to
teaching ideas and a monthly close-up on No Child Left Behind
reform in specific educational areas (elementary education,
science education, etc.). A news center also provides users with
links to the latest pro-NCLB news stories. Most importantly this
site provides easy-to-access links to the Department of
Education web pages containing information on the legislation,
regulations, and guidance of NCLB for administrators.
Research for Action
http://www.researchforaction.org/
This web site is maintained by Research for Action, the
Philadelphia-based non-profit group that is committed to
increase awareness about school reform by sharing their research
with the public. Research for Action's work ranges from
"formative evaluation of educational programs to broad-scale
policy research carried out in collaboration with other
organizations, both local and nationwide." Through a
collaborative inquiry process that brings educators, parents,
and students into the evaluation process, Research for Actions
web site and various publications represent the perspectives of
many "different voices and visions"
regarding school reform. Their site provides access to their
many projects (over thirty), both in progress and completed.
Some of these projects include: The Philadelphia Research
Project, documenting the changes in Philadelphia's public school
system under the current state takeover; The Urban Systemic
Program (USP) designed to reform math, science, and technology
instruction; The Talent Development High school and many others.
The site also provides users access to a myriad of publications
and additional resources for teachers, administrators, parents,
and students. This site is a must-visit for anyone interested in
urban school reform. |