Open-access E-journal for 
International Scholars, Practitioners, and Students of Multicultural Education

ISSN: 1559-5005
Copyright © 1999-2006 by 
Electronic Magazine of Multicultural Education

THIS ISSUE
(SPRING 2004: vol. 6, no. 1)

Theme: Multicultural Education Curriculum for Social Studies


ARTICLES:
 Gallavan & Putney
HalgaoMule •  Ndura & Lafer •  Porfilio & McClary

INSTRUCTIONAL IDEAS:
Betts
Kidney-Cummins

REVIEWS:
Art Books
Multimedia

CONTRIBUTORS

+++

Previous Issues
Call for Papers
Call for Reviewers
Issue Themes
Acknowledgments
About EMME
About the Editors

Heewon Chang, Ph. D.
Editor-in-Chief

Christopher Bittenbender, Ph. D.
Copy Editor
 
Hwa Young Caruso,  Ed. D. &  John Caruso, Jr. , Ph. D.
Art Review Editors 
?
Assistant Editor

Eastern University
Education Department
1300 Eagle Road
St. Davids, PA,
19087-3696




“AFRICA IS NOT A COUNTRY”: 
Reflections on the Teaching About Africa in Elementary Social Studies Classrooms

Lucy Mule
Smith College
U. S. A.

ABSTRACTIn this article, I encourage teachers to think about why, what, and how they teach about Africa in elementary social studies classrooms and to reflect on ways in which current standards for K-8 social studies at the national and state levels allow for the inclusion of Africa in the curriculum. I highlight some instructional approaches that can stimulate students to learn about Africa in powerful, engaging, and meaningful ways. I emphasize that instruction about Africa should target three main goals: confront stereotypes, cultivate interest in students, and develop “essential” knowledge in students.

Curriculum Standards and Teaching about Africa in Elementary Social Studies Classrooms 
Strategies to Teach About Africa in K-8 Social Studies 
Some Concluding Remarks

Endnotes

References


Recently a group of teachers at Valley (pseudonym) elementary school in northeastern United States invited me to sit in and help out where I could as they planned and implemented a 10-day curriculum program about Africa. The teachers drew inspiration from curriculum guides developed by the Outreach Program of the African Studies Center of Boston University. The Outreach program seeks to increase awareness and knowledge of Africa by providing information, materials, and services to schools, libraries, museums, the media, and community groups in New England and beyond.1  While relying on curriculum guides to some extent, the teachers at Valley elementary, for the most part, utilized knowledge gleaned from their many years of experience teaching a diverse student population. Their work prompted me to ask three related questions: Why, what, and how do teachers in America’s classrooms teach about Africa?2 [paragraph 1]

In this article, I encourage teachers to think about why, what, and how they teach about Africa in elementary social studies classrooms and reflect on ways in which current standards for K-8 social studies at the national and state levels allow for the inclusion of Africa in the curriculum. I highlight some instructional approaches that can stimulate students to learn about Africa in powerful, engaging, and meaningful ways. I emphasize that instruction about Africa should target three main goals: confront stereotypes; cultivate interest in students; and develop “essential” knowledge in students. Thoughts shared in this article are derived from literature review and insights gleaned from listening to and observing teachers in an elementary school setting. [paragraph 2]

Curriculum Standards and Teaching about Africa in Elementary Social Studies Classrooms

Standards for social studies at the national, state, and local levels emphasize the need for students to be exposed to cultural diversity within the United States as well as to the knowledge about regions, peoples, and cultures outside of the United States. In the discussion that follows, I use the National Council for Social Studies Standards (NCCS) of 1994 and the Massachusetts History and Social Science Curriculum Framework (Massachusetts Department of Education, 2003) to reflect on and highlight some of the opportunities they provide for teachers interested in the teaching about Africa. Strands one, three and nine of the NCCS provide several reasons for teaching about Africa in social studies. Some of the same reasons are echoed in the Massachusetts curriculum framework. [paragraph 3]

Strand one of NCCS focuses on culture. This strand acknowledges that cultural diversity is an undeniable reality in the United States and that a sizeable population claims deep cultural links with Africa. Africa would be studied under this strand because Americans of African descent trace their cultural heritage to Africa. The Black population in the United States comprises both voluntary immigrants and those Africans who came to the United States involuntarily through the transatlantic slave trade (Ogbu, 1991). [paragraph 4]

A similar emphasis on culture is evident in the Massachusetts History and Social Science Curriculum Framework, which is organized around themes. The theme in the Grade 2 curriculum, for instance, is titled “E Pluribus Unum: From Many, One,” and offers an excellent opportunity to introduce students to the continent of Africa. The learning standards in this theme expect students to explore their own family’s history and learn about distinctive achievements, customs, events, places, or landmarks from long ago and from around the world. According to the standards, the chief purpose of the Grade 2 curriculum is to help students understand that American citizenship embraces all kinds of people, regardless of race, ethnicity, gender, religion, and national origin. Students are expected to learn that American students come from all countries and continents in the world. The standards expect students to be able to explain the difference between a continent and a country and give examples of each; on a map of the world, locate the continent, regions, or countries from which students, their parents, guardians, grandparents, or other relatives or ancestors came; and with the help of family members and the school librarian, describe traditional food, customs, sports and games, and music of the place they came from. Some teachers at grade 2 use the standards to teach about diversity and Africa as part of that diversity. [paragraph 5]

The focus in Strand three of the NCCS is people, places, and environment. Under this strand, students are expected to study Africa to develop their spatial views and geographic perspectives of the world. Africa, after all, is the second largest continent in the world and home to 1 out of every 10 humans (Hume, 1996). The continent has fifty-four countries with more than 2,000 ethnic groups and their attendant languages and cultures (Eyoh, 1999). It spans seven time zones and takes longer to travel from Dakar, Senegal, in the West to Nairobi, Kenya, in the east than to fly from New York to London (Daddieh, 1999). The underlying assumption in teaching about the expanse and diversity of Africa is that studying about other countries and cultures helps broaden American students’ perspectives about the socio-physical world inhabited by different peoples of the world. It presumably allows students to develop a better appreciation of other cultures and provides them with a valuable opportunity to develop more humanistic and realistic views of the peoples of those cultures. This theme is echoed in the Massachusetts History and Social Science Curriculum Framework for grades six and seven. Students in these grades are expected to learn about the past and current information on a variety of African countries, their geography, economy, politics and customs. 
[paragraph 6]

The emphasis in strand nine of the NCCS is on global connections. Africa would be studied under this strand to facilitate the understanding that the world is becoming more interconnected and interdependent. The students, through an historical and critical examination of past and current issues and trends in Africa, are expected to acquire an understanding of the social, political, economic, as well as cultural issues that face Africa and how these are connected to their society and the world. While this is a daunting task for students at any level of schooling, the expectation that American students learn about the Other to understand themselves and their place in the world better is becoming a condition for intelligent citizenship. NCCS (1994) explains that  “[t]he primary purpose of social studies is to help young people develop the ability to make informed and reasoned decisions for the public good as citizens of a culturally diverse, democratic society in an interdependent world.”  [paragraph 7]

Teachers find broad guidelines such as the ones provided by the NCCS and Massachusetts History and Social Science Curriculum Framework as well as those developed at the local levels useful in making decisions about what to teach. However, the fact of the matter is that there is a discontinuity between the goals expressed in such guidelines and their translation into practice at the school and classroom levels. The stubborn reality remains that the system continues to produce students who are largely disengaged about Africa. Research indicates that there has been little shift in how Africa is viewed by the majority of students in U. S. classrooms. Hume (1996) noted that the majority of students have knowledge about Africa that is riddled with misconceptions, stereotypes, and bias. Critics see a media that depicts Africa in largely negative terms as the main culprit. The most common images of Africa in the media either depict Africa as a place of turmoil, diseases, drought, illiteracy, war, famine, and poverty (Fair, 1993) or as a vast jungle where animals freely roam the streets and villages. Another likely culprit is the literature read by many American students. In a study that examined the images of Africa and Africans prevalent in juvenile literature, Yenika-Agbaw (1996) found that Africa is portrayed as natural and romantic, images that are not so distant from the images held by American students in the 50's and 60’s. A 1967 survey quoted by Beyer (1969) that collected data from 3,259 seventh and twelfth graders revealed that these students viewed Africa as:

… a primitive, backward, underdeveloped land with no history—a hot, strange land of jungles and deserts, populated with wild animals, such as elephants, tigers, and snakes and by black naked savages, cannibals and pygmies. Missionaries and witchdoctors vie for the control of the natives, who live in villages, are prone to superstition and disease and hunt with spears and poison darts when not sitting in front of their huts beating on drums (p. 9).


How do teachers who are committed to the teaching about Africa teach in ways that address the standards, develop in students a more nuanced understanding of Africa, and transform students’ thinking and engagement with Africa? [paragraph 8]

Strategies to Teach About Africa in K-8 Social Studies 

In reviewing the literature, I noted that teachers who are successful in teaching about Africa in U. S. classrooms consciously aim to: 1) teach about Africa in ways that increase students’ knowledge about Africa without reinforcing student misconceptions, stereotypes, and bias about Africa that they may already have; 2) cultivate healthy curiosity about Africa in students; and 3) engage issues that relate to Africa in an integrated way (Beane, 1995) that promotes critical thinking or what Wiggins & McTighe (1998) term as “mature understanding” in their students. In this section, I discuss strategies, some of which it seems to me worked for the Valley teachers, that teachers could use to address these three goals. [paragraph 9]

Teaching to Confront Myths and Stereotypes About Africa

Since much of what students know about Africa is derived from the media, successful teachers spend more time focusing on confronting myths and stereotypes and presenting a nuanced and balanced view of the countries, peoples, and issues in Africa. One common myth that teachers seek to challenge is Africa as a homogenous land mass or a country as opposed to a continent. Johnston & Brown (1998) suggest an activity that I also have found to be successful when modified and used in college classrooms. Interestingly enough it is a common assumption held by some students in my college education courses that there is one homogenous system of education in “Africa.” To confront the common misuse of the term “Africa” and to guide students to an understanding of the diversity in the continent— geographically, culturally, linguistically, and politically—Johnston & Brown suggest displaying visibly in the classroom the poster “How Big is Africa?,” a 17 x 22 inches poster in which the maps of the United States, China, and Europe are drawn to scale and placed inside the continent of Africa. They suggest that students be guided in an exploration of such questions as: how does the size of Europe compare to the size of Africa? Judging from this map, do you think size alone can tell whether something is a continent, a country, or a state? Name all the countries you can on the continent of Europe. Now do the same for the continent of Africa. Do you know more about one than the other? [paragraph 10]

Crofts (1993) offers additional suggestions for teaching to confront stereotypes about Africa and advises teachers to choose one country and teach it well instead of attempting to cover the entire continent; seek commonalities in human experiences shared by African and U. S. students; promote the idea that students have something to learn from African societies; and avoid undue emphasis on problems, disease, malnutrition, drought, and illiteracy that tends to perpetuate existing stereotypes. The current discussions about HIV/AIDS especially in the middle school levels easily render themselves to affirming existing stereotypes in students about African promiscuity or prostitution. I became acutely aware of this while watching my middle school daughter prepare a project on HIV/AIDS in Africa that she was expected to present to her social studies class. As Stewart (1999) argues,

[s]ensationalized coverage by the popular media likely informs students about HIV/AIDS in Africa. Rather than dismiss these articles or concerns as unacademic, it is important to ask the class to reflect on the indiscriminate use of shocking statistics and stereotypes about African sexual behavior.... Popular media coverage can promote a fear of contagion spread by foreigners and create an us-versus-them equation that keeps the disease at a safe distance from our daily lives. This fear reinforces stereotypes about Africa as a chronically diseased place and obscures the historical link between local and global economies and the high prevalence of infectious diseases in Africa. (p. 90) [paragraph 11]

The same sensationalist approach is evident in the way the Rwanda genocide of 1994 has been presented in mainstream America. Newbury (1998) notes that “[f]ocusing on the drama [of the genocide], reporting in the west often served to strengthen stereotypes of African tribalism and barbarism; it thus served to obscure rather than enhance understanding of these events” (p. 74). Teachers who wish to focus on HIV/AIDS or other forms of “crises” such as civil wars, genocide, famine, and illiteracy in African countries must do so with an awareness of the stereotypes that can result when students are over-exposed to problems and underexposed to historical specificity and dynamism of these problems, the human agency in confronting these problems, and the global interconnectedness in the persistence of the problems. [paragraph 12]

Teaching About Africa to Cultivate Interest and Curiosity About the Continent and Its Peoples

Elementary students love hearing stories about people’s experiences. Usually these stories are not contained in most teaching materials. One way that successful teachers make information come alive in their classrooms is to invite adults from the community who have lived in Africa to speak about specific topics in specific countries (i.e. politicians, journalists, activists, doctors, farmers, bankers, teachers, and writers). They are careful to choose guest speakers who complement the teaching of a particular concept, topic or country that is already being taught in the classroom. One way to cultivate interest and curiosity in students is to use the Know/ Want-to-know/ Have-Learned (KWL) approach.3 The teacher guides students in an exploration of what they know about the topic or country before the invited guest arrives. They also draw a list of things they want to know about the topic or country. After the presentation, students can discuss and record what they have learned and what else they are curious to know about the focus country or topic. The teacher could follow up with having students conduct library research on topics/issues of interest to them. In using this strategy one needs to be careful to move away from overemphasizing the “tourist” approach with its narrow focus on the “three F” mentality: food, festivals, and fairs.4  When the focus is on the strange and exotic, stereotypes and misconceptions that students may have are reinforced. [paragraph 13]

Another way to cultivate in students a healthy curiosity is to establish pen pals and other forms of communication with students in same or similar grades in African countries. Numerous websites such as <http://www.iearn.org/about/index.html>
and <http://www.ptpi.org/programs/pen_pals.jsp> exist where electronic communications between students is possible. Teachers find that not only is receiving a letter from another country fun and exciting for children, but it also lessens the emotional and psychological distance between African nations and the United States. By communicating with African peers, American students can learn directly about other people’s daily lives in other places.  They will notice similarities and differences and hopefully this direct contact will dispel what inaccurate perceptions American students have about Africa, humanizing people who would otherwise remain remote and unknown. [paragraph 14]

In addition to facilitating contact between African and American students by mail, teachers can also create direct communication between African and American students who attend the same school in the United States.  Teachers at Valley elementary have implemented this strategy.  During their 10-day “Africa is Not a Country” program, teachers took pictures of all the African students in the school and hung them in a visible space. They helped students work on a narrative about themselves that accompanied the pictures. In doing so, these teachers drew the student body’s attention to their peers’ unique heritage, piquing other learners’ curiosity about their countries of origin in Africa. Highlighting African students’ cultures and experiences is likely to raise the student body’s interest in and knowledge of Africa. It also is a powerful way of validating African students in the school who might otherwise be marginalized.
[paragraph 15]

Teaching About Africa to Develop Essential Knowledge in Students

The way the social studies curriculum is organized in many schools reflects fragmentation based on geographical regions or academic disciplines. Africa is often taught as a discrete unit totally unconnected to other knowledge that students are learning.  Beane (1995), a staunch supporter of curriculum integration, explains the rationale behind curriculum integration:

Curriculum integration is not simply an organizational device requiring cosmetic changes or realignments in lesson plans across various subject areas. Rather, it is a way of thinking about what schools are for, about the sources of curriculum, and about the uses of knowledge. Curriculum integration begins with the idea that the sources of curriculum ought to be problems, issues, and concerns posed by life itself...such concerns fall into two spheres: 1) self- or personal concerns and 2) issues and problems posed by the larger world. Taking this one step further, we might say that the central focus of curriculum integration is the search for self- and social meaning. (p. 116) [paragraph 16]

 

Building on the need for curriculum to be organized in a way that teaches essential knowledge to students, Wiggins & McTighe (1998) urge teachers to focus on “big ideas.” They posit that  “[w]ithout a focus on linchpin ideas that have lasting value, students may be left with easily forgotten fragments of knowledge” (p. 11). Presenting fragmented knowledge about Africa is more likely to reinforce stereotypes. It also fails to cultivate interest and curiosity in students. Instead of presenting fragmented information about Africa that is disconnected from everything else that students are learning in social studies, teachers using the integrated curriculum design model would focus on the cultivation of in-depth knowledge in a connected way that transforms students’ thinking about, and engagement with, Africa. [paragraph 17]

Newspapers are a powerful way to gather current information on issues facing various parts of Africa. A number of websites including <http://www.africaonline.com> provide access to online newspapers from African countries. One teacher at Valley elementary posts selected pages of newspapers from countries in Africa on a bulletin board outside her classroom. She constantly leads her students in the analysis of the content depending on the issue she is teaching in the classroom. Newspapers, when read critically, offer a way for students to understand concepts such as democracy, racism, immigration, human rights, hunger, war, environmental degradation, urbanization, and peace in a more integrated and globally-connected way. An analysis of newspaper clips covering elections in Kenya, for instance, could be used to teach the concept of democracy, its challenges, and promises for young nations. The conceptions and practice of democracy in Kenya could be compared to the American experience. For instance, teachers could explore the allegation of election fraud in both countries and how this might affect the process of democracy. Excerpts from South African newspapers about Mandela’s post-apartheid government could be used to discuss intricacies of forming new democracies against the backdrop of the racist apartheid system, and how the South African situation is similar or/and different as well as interconnected to America’s. Newspaper clips from Zimbabwe on the government stand on white settlers and land ownership could be related to a discussion about race and racism and the Native American experience in the United States. Newspaper reports on human rights violations, domestic abuse, and hunger in any African country could lead into an exploration of the nature of similar concerns in the United States and at the global level. [paragraph 18]

Oral history projects are useful vehicles for students to see into the lives of people in their neighborhood and how they are affected by some of these global issues. Students can interview individuals who they know or who live in their community about events that center on any number of global issues. Additionally, students can read biographies and autobiographies or watch film documentaries of individuals in African countries on how they have been affected by war, hunger, racism, colonialism, disease, and urbanization among other global concerns. Students can also adopt an issue in a particular country in Africa and develop a project designed to raise awareness about the issue and to foster a sense of connectedness to those affected by it. This more “empathetic” approach to understanding issues facing African countries offers an opportunity for students to engage in meaningful learning that is more likely to lead to mature understandings. Empathy is understood here in a Freirean way to mean a disciplined effort to understand other people’s experiences in a way that leads to knowledge of oneself and the world around them.
[paragraph 19]

Some Concluding Remarks

It is important that students in U. S. social studies classrooms learn about Africa for many reasons, some of which are addressed in this article. It is equally important that teachers reflect on why, what, and how they teach about Africa to their students. While existing social studies standards may act as pointers with regard to when to include information about Africa in the curriculum, it is the teacher who ultimately determines what and how knowledge about Africa is taught each day in the classroom. The teaching and learning about African peoples, countries, and issues in America’s social studies classrooms would be enhanced if at least two basic beliefs are widely shared by teachers. The first belief is that the major goal of teaching about Africa in the first place is to instill in students some knowledge about Africa that transforms their thinking about the continent and its peoples. Teachers who believe in efficacy of teaching about Africa in ways that offer a balanced and nuanced knowledge about the continent are more likely to use strategies that challenge the hegemonic grip that continues to characterize the intellectual production of the non-American Other. Denigrating the Other, a strategy that has historically been used successfully in the colonial master-subject relationship to sustain power hierarchies, works only if stereotypes about the Other are allowed to thrive. Breaking these power structures requires teachers to spend more time focusing on confronting myths and stereotypes and teaching their students to avoid faulty and unproductive generalizations about Africa. Such teachers understand that using simplistic information that perpetuates stereotypes is a great disservice to their students. [paragraph 20]

A second belief that needs to be shared among teachers who teach about Africa is that the knowledge students acquire in the process of learning about Africa endures beyond the classroom. In other words, it is transformative knowledge that has what Wiggins & McTighe (1998) call “lasting value.” Teachers who approach the teaching of Africa with this understanding seize and build on the curiosity and intellectual capacity of their students to engage them in an in-depth analysis of issues in Africa using a variety of engaging strategies. The primary concern for such teachers is to develop a wider knowledge base that their students will need to effectively understand and function in their local and global contexts. I believe that a reflective approach to the teaching about Africa in U. S. social studies classrooms can impact students’ knowledge about Africa in significant ways. [paragraph 21]

Endnotes

1. See African Studies Center, Boston University. Retrieved March 5, 2004, from http://www.bu.edu/africa/outreach/index.html.

2. Special thanks to Caitlin Daniel, Smith College, for her research assistance.

3. See Pike and Mumper (2004) for a detailed analysis of the K-W-L procedure.

4. See Banks (2003) for a discussion on the levels of integration of ethnic content.

References

Banks, J. (2003). Teaching strategies for ethnic studies. New York: Ally and Bacon.

Beane, J. (1995). Curriculum integration and the disciplines of knowledge. Phi Delta Kappan, 76, 642-644.

Beyer, B. (1969) Africa south of the Sahara: A resource and curriculum guide.  New York, NY: Thomas Y. Crowell Company.

Crofts, M. (1993). Teaching about Africa in elementary schools. Retrieved March 2, 2004, from http:// www.bu.edu/africa/outreach/tips/teach2.html

Daddieh, C. K. (1999). Concept mapping and country adoption as tools for teaching about Africa in M. Bastian and  J. Parpart (Eds.). Great ideas for the teaching about Africa (pp. 203-210). Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

Eyoh, D. (1999). Teaching culture and politics with African cinema in M. Bastian and  J. Parpart (Eds.). Great ideas for the teaching about Africa (pp. 13-22). Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

Fair, J. (1993). War, famine, and poverty: Race in the construction of Africa’s media image. Journal of Communication Inquiry, 17(2), 5-22.

Hume, S. (1996). A Resource for teaching about Africa. Eric Resource Guide. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED416115)

Johnson, D., & Brown, B. (1998). How big is Africa? Social Education, 62(5), 278-282.

Massachusetts Department of Education. (2003). Massachusetts history and social science curriculum framework. Retrieved March 2, 2004, from http://www.doemass.org/frameworks/current.html

National Council for the Social Studies. (1994). Expectations of excellence: Curriculum standards for social studies. Washington, D.C.: Author.

Newbury, D. (1998). Understanding genocide. African Studies Review, 41(1), 73-97.

Ogbu, J. (1991). Immigrant and Involuntary minorities in comparative perspective. In M. Gibson and J. Ogbu (Eds.). Minority status and schooling: A comparative study of immigrant and involuntary minorities (pp. 3-33). New York: Garland.

Pike, K., & Mumper, H. (2004). Making nonfiction and other informational texts come alive: A practical approach to reading, writing, and using nonfiction and other informational texts across the curriculum. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.

Stewart, K. (1999). Confronting stereotypes about HIV/AIDS and Africans. In M. Bastian & J. Parpart (Eds.) Great Ideas for the teaching about Africa (pp. 89-101). Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

Wiggins, G., & McTighe, J. (1998). Understanding by design. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.

Yenika-Agbaw, V. (1996). Postcolonialism and multicultural literacy: Images of Africa in literature for children and young adults. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Pennsylvania State University, University Park.


Lucy Mule is Assistant Professor in the Department of Education and Child Study, Smith College. Her research interests are multicultural education as it relates to teacher education. She teaches a variety of courses in education, including comparative education, multicultural education, literacy in cross-cultural perspective as well as a teaching methods seminar for student teachers. She is a co-director of the Urban Education Initiative at Smith College. She also taught high school in Kenya for six years. (You may contact the author at lmule@smith.edu; and the editors of EMME at emme@eastern.edu.)

Recommended Citation in the APA Style:

Mule, L. (2004). "Africa is not a country":  Reflections on the teaching about Africa in elementary social studies classrooms. Electronic Magazine of Multicultural Education, 6(1), 21 paragraphs. Retrieved your-access-month date, year, from http://www.eastern.edu/publications/emme/2004spring/mule.html